It’s not always easy being around your ex — or seeing them move on with someone else.

In PEOPLE’s exclusive sneak peek at Wednesday’s episode ofThe Hills: New Beginnings,Kaitlynn Carterbegins to feel uncomfortable seeing exBrody Jennergetting cozy with his new flame,Amber Davis, while the castmates are out together.

When the pair leaves the table, Kaitlynn, 32, opens up about the dynamic of the situation after Justin, 39, asks how she’s feeling.

The Hills

“Did you not know [about his new relationship] or he didn’t say anything?” Justin asks, leading Kaitlynn to confirm that she was unaware of Brody’s current dating situation.

The Hills

The Hills

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Justin then tells Kaitlynn that he’s “here” for her if she needs the support, and she thanks him for extending the offer.

The Hills

PEOPLE confirmed in August 2019 thatBrody and Kaitlynn “decided to amicably separate"just one year aftertheir Indonesian wedding. It was later revealed thattheir union was not legally binding.

“The circumstances of what happened after our split catered to that negative s—,” Brody said while speaking to Kaitlynn. “The whole lesbian thing was gnarly, because in our entire relationship you never expressed that you had any interest in females whatsoever.”

“I don’t think that’s fair or totally true to say,” Kaitlynn responded, to which Brody replied, “We had some fun, but what I’m saying, yes, but you said to me that you weren’t into girls.”

Brody, for his part, had a three-month fling withJosie Cansecothatended in October 2019. The reality star, who later sparked dating rumors with other women, including personal stylistBriana Jungwirthand TikTok starDaisy Keech, wasfirst linked to Amber in July 2020. InThe Hills: New Beginnings’season 2 trailer,Audrina Patridgerevealed that she shared a kiss with Brody.

source: people.com